13 October 2020
Major Ruben A. Oliver
Troop B Commander

Cold Case Tuesday: State Police continue to investigate the 1976 death of a New York City woman in Franklin County.

State Police continue to investigate the 1976 death of a New York City woman in Franklin County. Forty-four years ago 30-year-old Francine M. Mitchell, was visiting the St. Regis Mohawk Reservation and staying with relatives from New York City.

On October 11, 1976, at about 4:30 a.m., Mitchell was observed by New York State Troopers sleeping behind the wheel of her vehicle, on the south shoulder of State Route 37 in Hogansburg, New York. 

Shortly after the troopers passed, a homeowner was awakened by a door bell, and witnessed the victim standing with another person on the sidewalk in front of the residence.  By the time the homeowner’s spouse got to the door, the victim lying on the sidewalk injured and police were called.

The same Troopers who observed the victim in her car, responded within minutes and located her lying in a field, south of where her vehicle was parked and badly injured.  The victim was able to communicate some details before being transported to a hospital in Massena, where she underwent emergency surgery for a ruptured liver.  The victim suffered a heart attack during surgery and went into a coma.  She died three days later as a result of brain swelling.   

An investigation revealed the victim had been out drinking the night before with friends and was witnessed to be passed out in her car, where her attackers found her and brutally attacked and robbed her of her purse.  The assault continued on the sidewalk in front of the homeowner’s residence where the witnesses saw her.

Two men from Akwesasne were identified as possible suspects and within hours were interviewed.  One refused to cooperate and fled the area when the victim died. The other suspect was arrested for possessing stolen property belonging to the victim and plead guilty.

The suspect who fled the area was located months later hiding out in an apartment in New York City, where he was arrested for Murder and transported back to Franklin County.   The case was presented to a Franklin County Grand Jury, but no indictments were obtained. 

No other arrests have been made in this investigation.  

This investigation remains under investigation by the New York State Police, Troop B Violent Crimes Investigation Team. A billboard with Mitchell’s photo has been put up on State Route 37 where the crime occured. Any person with information is encouraged to contact VCIT Investigator Jonathan Garrow at 518-897-2040.    



You must be logged in to view this item.

This area is reserved for members of the news media. If you qualify, please update your user profile and check the box marked "Check here to register as an accredited member of the news media". Please include any notes in the "Supporting information for media credentials" box. We will notify you of your status via e-mail in one business day.